Scotland’s Economy
A summary of discussions on 14 March 2026, based on notes compiled by facilitators Val Brown, Tim Rideout and William Thomson
The current state of Scotland’s economy was described as docile and dominated by foreign owners, public sector heavy with the NHS, Public Health Scotland and councils accounting for 45% of GDP, and a weak 3rd sector i.e. charities, social enterprises and community groups delivering essential services.
The private sector is weaker now than in the past, and public companies listed on the Stock Exchange are mostly gone. Strengths are Fintech (Financial technologies), IT (Information technology), and Energy, particulary renewables, though improved grid systems are needed. Scotland is self sufficient in many areas of food production. Agriculture and fisheries generate strong export revenue streams, but Scotland’s share of the UK fishing fund is tiny compared to the size of its contribution (8% of funding for 60% of both fleet and seafood exports). Taking full control of the industry is strongly recommended.
Economic foundations
Opinions varied on how to run the economy, but there was broad consensus on Scotland’s economic foundations.
- Resources – Scotland is well endowed with natural resources but an extractive economy means little benefit is retained.
- Human capital – Scotland’s people are a key resource that is also extracted due to scarcity of rewarding jobs and affordable housing. Quality is high but quantity low as more, largely young, people, emigrate every year, including to England.
- Infrastructure – much of Scotland’s infrastructure is foreign and privately owned. The lack of investment, in e.g. ports, transport and energy networks has allowed major assets to be run down or decommissioned.
- Inventiveness and initiative – Scotland produces a wealth of talent across the arts, commercial and industrial sectors. Much of this is exported in search of business opportunities and a high standard of living.
Stepping stones to a healthy economy
Moving to a resilient, wellbeing economy requires structural change in key areas; land ownership, taxation, ownership of energy and transport (including harbours and ferry ports), and housing. The question is, what powers does the Scottish Government have now to redistribute wealth and grow the economy? Opportunities exist but action is constrained by an apparent lack of understanding of how the economy actually works. Special advisors offer continuity across elections but promote an orthodox, neoliberal agenda that favours the current extractive economic model.
Some of Scotland’s major industries are problematic and need regulation, e.g. over-processed food makes people ill, intensive agriculture destroys land, tourism takes priority over residents, property is for speculation not housing people. Manufacturing and service sectors are hollowed out by private investors. These issues can be tackled by a state sponsored development plan with local supply chains and manufacturing capacity to grow the industrial sector. Reinstating a Scottish stock exchange is also recommended.
Shifting Economic Models
It hasn’t always been this way. Post WWII the UK government built a healthy economy for the good of the people. Neoliberalism began to replace Keynesian economics in the early 1970s and finally took over in 1979 when Margaret Thatcher got elected. If it took over in six years it can be dismantled in another six.
Decolonization
Whether or not Scotland meets all the criteria to be declared a colony, there is overwhelming evidence of economic colonization and colonial health syndrome is a demographic reality. ‘Social murder’ is a term used to describe the higher death rate during periods of austerity. Statistics on alcoholism, diabetes, domestic violence, drug deaths, obesity, suicide and chronic health problems speak for themselves. Only the state can intervene to protect the wellbeing of people and the economy. Educating and empowering the population are important next steps.
Return to National Convention page Read Scotland & Europe Discussion Notes Read Scotland’s Energy Discussion Notes
